Jump to content Jump to search

CLIMATE CHANGE IS IMPACTING VITICULTURE AND WINEMAKING AT A RAPID PACE

We could either consider this topic too hot (excuse the pun) in that global warming has become so politically charged and a wine club is supposed to be about an apolitical pastime. But if you truly have even the slightest passion for wine, you simply cannot ignore the topic of global warming simply because it is a stark reality for the people who cultivate Vitus vinifera and make wine, which you drink as your pastime.

For viticulturists and winemakers, there are two major factors that have been affecting their livelihoods:
1) It’s getting warmer. Whatever the reason for this, it is an irrefutable fact. Besides the statistics from NASA and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration showing that the global temperature has risen a full 1°C (1.8°F) from before the industrial revolution (yes, this hints that the phenomenon is at least partially influenced by mankind, but no need to go there for this discussion), and eight of the ten warmest years on record have occurred in the last decade, viticulturists are seeing it in their vineyards: Vines are budding and flowering earlier resulting in harvests having to take place on average ten days to two weeks sooner than they did just a decade ago. For the winemaker, more heat means riper grapes with more sugar resulting in higher alcohol levels after fermentation along with higher acidity levels, and lower tannins, all of which change how they do their work in the cellar to maintain consistent taste profiles.
2) Extreme weather has become more common and unpredictable. Although warmer weather overall has resulted in milder winters, they’re not consistently stay mild. As we mentioned, vines have been coming out of dormancy early, but then a monthlong cold snap will come along to kill off swathes of vineyards, especially young and fragile vines before growing season even begins. In 2021, one of these frost snaps in April in France affected 90 percent of the country’s vineyards, resulting in the lowest wine production in France since the Second World War. Otherwise, the world is seeing more wildfires, floods, droughts, and severe hailstorms, all of which used to happen once a decade that are now happening on an annual basis, again, decimating vines.

GEOGRAPHY CHANGES IS WHERE WE’RE SEEING THE BIGGEST IMPACT

As we have discussed in previous wine club offerings, Vitus vinifera thrives in two wine belts (read our wine club edition on High Altitude Wines to learn more about the wine belts) that wrap around the world laterally, one north of the equator and one south of the equator. The different varietals of Vitus vinifera are mutations that have adapted to the range of climates within these wine belts. Varietals more tolerant of warmer temperatures grow well in the south of the Northern Hemisphere belt and in the north of the Southern Hemisphere belt and vice versa for varietals that have adapted to colder temperatures.
NASA_Temp_Index2.png
For the first time in the four or five centuries since we’ve been really paying attention, the climates within these wine belts are shifting to the point that some of the grapes more tolerant of colder weather are even thriving OUTSIDE of the belts, north of the Northern Hemisphere and south of the Southern Hemisphere. Examples where Vitus vinifera are now thriving where they did not before in the Northern Hemisphere are England, Belgium, Denmark, Norway and Sweden where white wines, sparkling wines and even some red varietals are being cultivated. Otherwise, within the wine belts, viticulturists are seeking higher ground where the temperature is cooler, moving from their tried-and-true cherished plots to avoid, rather than seek, the sun, harvesting earlier to avoid too much heat or untimely storms, or simply replanting with varietals that are better suited to the new climate or better resistant to certain weather conditions.

LUCKILY DIFFERENT VARIETALS HAVE ADAPTED TO DIFFERENT CLIMATES

The biggest news on the varietal shift is in France, of course, where appellations are the strictest in terms of which types of varietals are allowed to be included in an appellation, which is always based on region. After one too many challenging harvests, the infamous Bordeaux appellations are allowing seven new varietals into their blends, most of them not even native to the nation of France: Marselan, Touriga Nacional, Castets and Arinarnoa (cross of Cabernet Sauvignon and Tannat) for red; and and Alvarinho, Petit Manseng and Liliorila for white. Of course, this is news because France is so rigid in what varietals it allows in its appellation wines, but transplanted varietals are happening all over the world, which we will see for some of the wines we select for these wine clubs.
the-wine-belt.png
Source: https://winefolly.com/tips/start-planning-now-wine-harvest-season/

AND THEN OF COURSE THERE IS THE WORK IN THE CELLAR

We must never forget that wine does not happen naturally. Even for the most minimal intervention natural wine, human manipulation is necessary and robust. With climate change wreaking havoc on the normal growing process of varietals, blending has been one pivotal tool for achieving desired taste profiles or consistency. Of course this is nothing new about this (e.g., percentages of varietals in Bordeaux wines have always changed according to the growing seasons’ differing weather patterns), but we are seeing more of it everywhere. This and other types of manipulation are elevating the need for highly trained and educated oenologists and winemakers. No longer is it so easy to have a family estate assume that a family member can oversee the oenology and winemaking.

On the extreme end of human manipulation, we are also seeing more wineries foregoing vintages and employing a solera system, as is done with sherry, so that they can blend the many different expressions that have been coming from unpredictable harvests, blending over years, as opposed to a season, for taste and consistency. This practice is still in its infancy however, but it will certainly become more prevalent.

For this month’s wine club offerings and for the next three wine club offerings we will be selecting wines that have come about because of global warming and one or more of the following impacts. Without further ado, we will let the producers and wines do the demonstrating themselves. For this month we reached around the globe from California to Spain to Australia.

TARGETING THE RIGHT VARIETALS TO DEAL WITH DROUGHT AND BUSH FIRES

Featured April Amaro Wine Club Climate Change wine: Into The Black Worlds Apart Syrah McLaren Vale (2022)
VARIETALS: Syrah

Louis Schofield went from working a decade in wine retail and sommelier at restaurants to training under the famed winemaker Taras Ochota to learn to make what he was selling. He launched Worlds Apart Wines in 2017 with his fiancé, Hannah Jeffrey, with a goal to make wine as naturally as possible but without getting too hung up on the definition of “natural”. In fact, his idea was that making wine as naturally as possible was a way to make it taste better. But if tweaking things became necessary, so be it. Louis and Hannah were inspired by Burgundy, but the effects of climate change in South Australia unfortunately does not allow for Burgundy’s iconic Pinot Noir to thrive. Their insurance for survival has been varietals that can stand up to warmer temperatures, drought, and all-too-frequent bushfires that have become the reality of global warming for South Australia. Louis and Hannah farm only one small block, and they source the rest of their grapes from long established farmers throughout the Hills, Eden and Vale. In this block, however, is where they test and learn how to protect and nourish the land and soil, reduce water usage in both the vineyards and winery, and strive for full carbon neutrality, sharing their experience with whom they source the bulk of their grapes.
Louis_Schofield_and_Hannah_Jeffrey.png
Louis Schofield and Hannay Jeffrey, owners of Worlds Apart
For example, after the devastating 2020 bushfires, Louis and Hannah worked with their farmer partners to better protect the vineyards with trenches and clearing brush, but being careful not to disturb vital natural soils, native grasses, and other biodiversity on the farms. Because Vitus vinifera is not native to Australia, the challenge has been to find varietals that thrive in the unique changing climate of Australia. They found, or example, that Grenache is the grape to make Burgundian style wines in South Australia because the vines require less water. Syrah (aka Shiraz) is also a natural because of its ability to thrive in hotter climates, and then they have also increasingly been working with Nero d’Avola for its drought-resistant properties as drought has become another of South Australia’s global warming realities.

For this single-varietal Syrah wine, they used native yeast to ferment 60 percent of the grapes in whole cluster in open-top tanks for 10 days before even racking after then they were pressed into neutral French oak 225-500 liter barrels where the wine aged for four months and bottled without fining or filtering
FOOD PAIRINGS: Mediterranean-style chicken and lamb dishes, roast cuts in aromatic herbs, classic shawarmas, chargrilled kebabs, ratatouille, cassoulet, chickpea-focused dishes, eggplant, mushrooms and butterbeans dishes, barbecue.

RELYING ON A NATIVE VARIETAL THAT KNOWS THE TERRAIN BEST

Featured April Amaro Wine Club Climate Change wine: Celler Pardas Sus Scrofa (2022)
VARIETALS: Sumoll

Celler Pardas started when two growers from Penedès, Ramon Parera and Jordi Arnan, acquired an old estate called Can Comas in Alt Penedès, close to Sant Sadurni d’Anoia. The property surrounds an old medieval farm and spans 74 acres of forest and other crops (mainly cereal). The vineyards in the regions have for the most part followed the trend in Spain for the last few centuries of planting international varietals for their higher yields and marketplace familiarity. Ramon and Jordi decided from the start, though, that they would grow local grape varieties, namely Sumoll for red and Xarel-lo for white, even though they are lower yielding and more difficult to work with in the cellar to achieve drinkability. Their decision was based on their belief in maintaining the natural, native ecology of the terrain.
Before phylloxera, Sumoll was one of the most widely planted varietals throughout Catalonia, so it was not difficult for the Ramon and Jordi to find cuttings of old vines in the region to plant, and from here they incorporated the forest surrounding the vineyards into their oversight as well as the land bordering them to create an agrarian ecosystem, and they chose to live on the property to be as attuned as possible to the ecology. They started their viticulture enterprise by dry farming the vines (no irrigation) and not ploughing the soils to avoid erosion. However, global warming has created a twist – although the climate is usually humid enough to dry farm and leave the soil alone, in recent years it has barely rained.
PardasVineyards.png
So, although they believe firmly in spontaneous and native vegetal covers, which they have maintained and cared for during the last 30 years, the drought has forced the viticulturists to till the soils to avoid competition for water from the natural grasses. They have also been pruning the vines more, even though it reduces production, and pruning the leaves more, but with caution, keeping in mind the higher temperatures and the need for grape clusters to profit from the shade of the vine leaves. Lastly, they have brought forward the harvest dates by about fifteen days, looking for the optimal ripening point.

Yet the pair maintains (and other growers in the region agree and have followed suit) that their success lies largely with the native varietals as the vines are more symbiotic with the ecology of the area thus more adaptable to changing with adapting along with the many aspects of that is also being affected by global warming without too much dependence on human intervention.Insert your text here
Ramon_Parera_and_Jordi_Arnan.png
Ramon Parera and Jordi Arnan are hands-on in all aspects of the process.
So, although they believe firmly in spontaneous and native vegetal covers, which they have maintained and cared for during the last 30 years, the drought has forced the viticulturists to till the soils to avoid competition for water from the natural grasses. They have also been pruning the vines more, even though it reduces production, and pruning the leaves more, but with caution, keeping in mind the higher temperatures and the need for grape clusters to profit from the shade of the vine leaves. Lastly, they have brought forward the harvest dates by about fifteen days, looking for the optimal ripening point.

Yet the pair maintains (and other growers in the region agree and have followed suit) that their success lies largely with the native varietals as the vines are more symbiotic with the ecology of the area thus more adaptable to changing with adapting along with the many aspects of that is also being affected by global warming without too much dependence on human intervention.

The viticulturists are as natural in the cellar as they are in the fields. After hand harvesting, they let fermentation happen spontaneously with native yeasts and destem 50 percent of the grapes and combine them with 50 percent whole grapes with stems to allow for gravity to do its own fermentation work. Afterward, they age the pressed juice for 3 months in concrete tanks and the wine is neither stabilized nor clarified. Instead, before aging they use a mix of steel, concrete and oak for fermenting and élèvage to achieve different expressions.
Making a single-varietal Sumoll wine was no easy task. There is a reason why farmers in centuries past favored international varietals over the native Sumoll grape as it is not an easy to grape varietal to work with. As Jordi so poetically puts it, Sumoll is “the most masochistic grape there is.” But with lots of attention, they have managed to work its rusticity into a delicate, fresh table red wine.

FOOD PAIRINGS: fish stew with bell peppers, roasted vegetables and haloumi, duck confit, dishes that incorporate truffles, Ibérico pork dishes

REGION STEALING THE THUNDER OF ITS MORE FAMOUS SOUTHERN NEIGHBOR

Featured April Amaro Wine Club Climate Change wine: Dancing Crow Cabernet Sauvignon (2021)
VARIETALS: 76% Cabernet Sauvignon, 24% Merlot

The Dancing Crow estate is in the Lake County AVA (American Viticultural Area – read our wine club edition on Washington State Wines for more on what constitutes an AVA) in California, north of Napa County, where the world-renowned AVA Napa Valley is located. The vineyards in Lake County range are at about 430 meters to 460 meters (1,400 feet to 1,500 feet) above sea level in mountain foothills with volcanic soils; hence, traditionally viticulturists in the area have been most successful with white varietals that require shorter growing seasons and less heat. The best red wines from here have traditionally been blends as it is safer to grow multiple types of varietals considering the variability in taste profiles that come from different vines in high altitudes that are forced to grow their roots deep and shut down at night, both resulting in more chemical reactions than vines that get consistent sun and even less temperature variation (for more on high altitude wines read our wine club edition on High Altitude Wines). Blending the disparate results affords the winemaker some control over their products.
However, in recent years the climate in Lake County has shifted so that it resembles the temperature and growing seasons of Napa Valley to the south where single varietals are the norm as vines are less taxed and less chemically volatile. Add to this the cool air that blows off Clear Lake and the climate has become even more consistent than in Napa Valley, which has been experiencing not only hotter weather, but more unpredictable weather patterns and related events, such as fire and flooding to name the most frequent. In Lake County, the temperatures are getting 90 degrees Fahrenheit in the day during the summer but dropping to 50 at night according to its mountain climate.

So, while in Napa farmers are either harvesting earlier or figuring out ways to shade the grapes to avoid over-ripening due to global warming, Lake County now has the climate Napa did in the 1980s. On top of this, Lake County has natural advantages of mountain climates, such as clear air (the cleanest in California), drier air (fog is rare), and high intensity UV light (which results from both dry air and elevation), and the more challenging volcanic soil reduces pests and diseases from taking hold, enabling more environmentally sound farming practices.
DancingCrowVineyards.png
Dancing Crow is a family-owned and operated winery spanning four generations. They specialize in French-style wines. They started out with Sauvignon Blanc, which remains their flagship crop. On the red side, they worked with 30 different varietals and produced bright, concentrated, interesting blends. But now with global warming, the family can take a page out of the Napa Valley book with single varietals that require consistency and sun, namely Cabernet Sauvignon. Of course, being accustomed to blending, especially French-style blending, they were not afraid to go Bordeaux-style and add Merlot to soften this product, which they let go through a second malolactic fermentation in French and Hungarian oak. With the unique high altitude and volcanic properties, they have created a Cabernet Sauvignon that easily rivals those coming from Napa Valley.

FOOD PAIRINGS: pot roast, steak and potatoes, beef stew, lamb dishes, red sauce pasta dishes, mushroom risotto, smoked tofu, hard cheeses.